The WNBA All-Star weekend just took a dramatic turn—Caitlin Clark, the league’s brightest new star and fan magnet, is officially out.

Despite the anticipation and excitement surrounding her participation—especially with the event happening in Indiana, her current basketball home—Clark announced she won’t be taking part in either the All-Star Game or the highly anticipated 3-point contest. Instead, she’s choosing rest and recovery.

In a heartfelt statement, Clark expressed her gratitude to the Indianapolis Host Committee and everyone involved in organizing the event. “I am incredibly sad and disappointed,” she said, “but I have to rest my body.” Still, she emphasized that she’ll be present at Gamebridge Fieldhouse to support her teammates and help coach Team Clark alongside Sandy Brondello.

This decision, though tough, seems like the right move. The All-Star Game, while exciting, ultimately doesn’t affect the season standings. With the Fever battling to stay in playoff contention, every regular season game matters more. Sitting this weekend out gives Clark nearly a full week to recuperate—time she clearly needs after a physically demanding rookie campaign.

Fans across the league have mostly responded with support and understanding. Yet, some rival fanbases—particularly those cheering for Angel Reese—took the opportunity to throw a few jabs, reigniting the ever-present rivalry. Reese herself is not without injury concerns, having missed a recent game, but the comparison continues to fuel debate among their passionate supporters.

As for Clark’s replacement in the All-Star Game, the WNBA announced that guard Brittney Sykes would step in. Interestingly, many fans had already voiced frustration that Sykes wasn’t selected originally. Known for her tenacious defense and energy, Sykes now gets her chance to shine on one of the league’s biggest stages.

But the bigger question might be: who will replace Clark in the 3-point contest?

Because the WNBA allows players outside the All-Star roster to participate, the door is wide open. And naturally, fans are calling for a Fever player to take her spot—it’s Indiana, after all. Several names are floating around:

Kelsey Mitchell, a reliable sharpshooter with a 36.4% 3-point shooting percentage this season, seems like an obvious choice. She has experience, a hometown advantage, and the game to compete on the big stage.

Lexie Hull, who has shot an impressive 46.7% from deep over the season (though she’s cooled off lately), also presents a strong case.

But the wildcard—the name drawing the most buzz—is Sophie Cunningham.

Cunningham has been red-hot lately, going 8-of-11 from downtown in her last three games and shooting nearly 39% on the season. More than just numbers, she’s become a fan favorite—so much so that her jersey sales recently exploded, with thousands sold almost instantly after a breakout performance against the Connecticut Sun.

Adding Cunningham wouldn’t just reward strong play—it would ignite the local crowd. She’s become arguably the second most popular player on the Fever roster behind Clark herself. Putting her in the spotlight could energize an event now lacking its biggest star.

While we wait for the official announcement, the All-Star weekend suddenly feels less electric without Clark. Fan interest has cooled, and some have even called the situation a “disaster.” The WNBA has come under fire recently for failing to protect players like Clark, with criticism pointing to rough, overly physical play and inconsistent foul calls that may have contributed to her fatigue and need for rest.

It’s a missed opportunity for the league, no doubt. But if the WNBA gets the 3-point contest replacement right—especially with someone like Sophie Cunningham—it might still salvage some of the magic. Fans came to see stars, and if the league can pivot smartly, Indiana could still give them a show worth remembering.

For now, Caitlin Clark’s absence is a reminder: even the brightest stars need rest. The season continues, and so does her journey. All eyes will be on who picks up the torch this weekend—and who’s ready to take their shot.