In a move that has fans buzzing and critics whispering, Dewanna Bonner is expected to sign with the Phoenix Mercury—again.

Yes, that Dewanna Bonner.

The seasoned veteran, known as much for her fierce competitiveness as her complex legacy, is returning to the desert, and not everyone is thrilled. For some, it’s a homecoming that adds strength and grit to a team chasing one last golden run. For others, it’s a risky bet that could derail chemistry, cut promising talent, and stir up old wounds.

Let’s get real: this isn’t just another signing. This is Phoenix sending a message—they’re going all in.

The Fallout in Indiana

Bonner’s departure from the Indiana Fever was less a mutual parting and more a quiet surrender. Despite her contributions, the Fever “caved,” letting go of a player many believed still had fuel in the tank. She got out—but not without leaving mixed feelings behind.

Her critics say she underperformed. Her defenders argue she was never fully utilized. Either way, she’s out. And now, she’s headed somewhere that knows her best—and might need her the most.

Chemistry or Chaos?

Reports suggest Bonner’s signing is “expected,” with ESPN and other outlets hinting it’s only a matter of when, not if. But one key question remains: where does she fit?

The Mercury already have a tight rotation. Star players are battling injuries (Satu Sabally is in a boot), the frontcourt is crowded, and team cohesion has been fragile all season. Bringing in a strong personality like Bonner could inspire a championship run—or ignite tensions that have long simmered under the surface.

One thing’s clear: someone has to go. And the writing’s on the wall for Kiana Williams, a player whose minutes have dwindled. She’s likely the odd one out in this high-stakes shuffle.

A “Consolation Prize”?

Some insiders aren’t exactly thrilled about the move, calling Bonner the “consolation prize” after Phoenix failed to land bigger targets. That’s harsh, but not without a point. The Mercury have flirted with other names—Aari McDonald, Michaela Onyenwere—but ultimately circled back to someone familiar.

Familiar doesn’t always mean safe. And it certainly doesn’t guarantee success.

Fans Are Split

Phoenix fans are divided. One half sees a veteran leader returning to finish what she started, bringing invaluable experience and leadership to a team that could use both. The other half sees this as a desperation play—an aging star stepping into a dynamic that may no longer fit her style.

And let’s not forget the fans in Indiana. If Bonner thought she’d escape the noise, she’s wrong. Expect her to be booed in Indy, not because of who she is—but because that’s sports. Loyalty is a fragile thing in the WNBA, and for many fans, it was broken the moment she left.

Can She Still Deliver?

No one questions Bonner’s impact when she’s locked in. She brings scoring, rebounding, length, and attitude. The Mercury don’t need her to be the star—they need her to be the glue. That’s a different role than she’s used to. Will she embrace it?

And will the younger core—Lexie Hull, Kit Laxa, and others—accept it?

The Bigger Picture

This move is about more than Bonner. It’s about Phoenix’s urgency. They’ve lost two in a row. Another loss seems imminent. The title window is cracking open just enough—and they’re trying to squeeze through.

Whether Bonner is the key or just a final gamble remains to be seen. But one thing’s for sure: this signing will either be remembered as a brilliant last stand… or the moment the Mercury bet too much on the past.

Because in the WNBA, second chances come with a cost.

And the whole league is watching.