What began as an off-camera friendship between former GMA3 co-hosts Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes has since evolved into one of the most talked-about and controversial relationships in daytime television. But while the pair’s romance now appears stronger than ever, the emotional fallout from their respective divorces has sent shockwaves through both of their families.

From Co-Hosts to Couple

The world learned of Robach and Holmes’ romantic involvement in November 2022 when paparazzi photos of the two vacationing together surfaced online. At the time, both were still publicly married—Holmes to lawyer Marilee Fiebig, and Robach to actor Andrew Shue.

The photos sparked a firestorm. Within weeks, ABC News pulled the duo from their anchoring duties on GMA3: What You Need to Know. After weeks of internal review and speculation, the network released an official statement on January 27, 2023, announcing that both Robach and Holmes would be parting ways with ABC.

“After several productive conversations with Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes about different options, we all agreed it’s best for everyone that they move on from ABC News,” the network stated, thanking them for their years of dedication and contributions.

The Unraveling of Two Marriages

As their relationship gained momentum in public, the private toll on their former partners became painfully clear. Holmes filed for divorce from Fiebig, his wife of 12 years, not long after the story broke. In December, Fiebig’s attorney released a statement expressing disappointment over Holmes’ behavior.

“We continue to be disappointed by T.J.’s lack of discretion, respect, and sensitivity toward Marilee and the party’s daughter,” the statement read. “Marilee has been touched by the outpouring of support and looks forward to a new beginning in this new year.”

The couple shares one daughter, Sabine, now 10, and Holmes was still actively parenting at the time the relationship became public. A birthday photo posted in August 2022 showed him being embraced by Sabine as he smiled over a birthday cake—a moment Amy Robach quietly liked on Instagram, months before the headlines erupted.

Silent Shifts and Social Signals

Though Robach has not publicly commented on the end of her marriage to Andrew Shue, the digital clues have been telling. Shue, known for his role in Melrose Place, scrubbed all photos of Robach from his Instagram shortly after news of her new relationship broke.

Despite the split, Robach continues to follow Fiebig on social media—a surprising detail that has raised eyebrows among fans and followers. Though she hasn’t liked any of Fiebig’s recent posts, the digital footprint suggests a complex emotional landscape—one that extends beyond a clean break.

Love Amid Fallout

Today, Robach and Holmes remain together, often spotted out in New York City and appearing comfortable in the public eye despite their dramatic exit from television. Their chemistry, undeniable to many, continues to draw attention—but it’s accompanied by a narrative of broken trust and fractured families.

What complicates the story further is how deeply intertwined the four individuals had become before the relationships ended. Robach and Holmes were known not only as co-anchors but as close friends. Their shared time on GMA3 made them familiar faces in America’s living rooms. Few expected the professional bond to evolve into something more personal—especially under such public scrutiny.

Children in the Crossfire

Though Robach and Shue did not have children together, both brought kids into the marriage from previous relationships and often shared their blended family life on social media. Those posts have since disappeared, and neither Robach nor Shue has commented on how their children are navigating the separation.

For Holmes, the situation is even more delicate. His daughter Sabine is still young, and the visible, abrupt shift in her father’s personal life has prompted concern from observers about how the public unraveling of the marriage could affect her.

A Future Under the Spotlight

While Robach and Holmes have both found happiness in each other, their love story has become a case study in how public relationships can collide with private lives. Their departure from ABC, the breakdown of two marriages, and the emotional ripple effects continue to make headlines.

But in the face of criticism, the couple appears unified. Whether they return to television or forge new paths, they’ve made it clear that their relationship is more than a headline.

Still, the shadow of what—and who—was left behind lingers. For their former spouses and families, the story isn’t just about new beginnings. It’s about processing what was lost and finding healing in the wake of a love story that began with friendship and ended with a storm.

For now, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes move forward—together—but with the understanding that the past isn’t easily left behind.