A storm is brewing at Fox News’ late-night juggernaut Gutfeld!, and its name is Tyrus. The former pro wrestler turned political commentator is now at the center of a growing viewer revolt, with longtime fans accusing him of hijacking the show and derailing the dynamic that once made it one of cable’s most popular programs.

Once praised for its witty banter and offbeat political commentary, Gutfeld! is facing some of the harshest criticism in its history. At the heart of the backlash is Tyrus, whose increasingly dominant presence has prompted calls for him to be removed from the show entirely.

“I Turn Off the TV When Tyrus Appears”

That quote, pulled from a now-viral post on X (formerly Twitter), is representative of a broader viewer sentiment echoing across social media platforms. Users on Reddit, YouTube comment sections, and discussion forums are voicing deep frustration with what many describe as Tyrus’s overbearing on-air behavior.

“He cuts everyone off,” one user complained. “It’s like watching someone crash a dinner party every single night.”

Another wrote, “I used to love Gutfeld! for its mix of humor and insight. Now I’m lucky if I make it five minutes in before I switch the channel.”

Hashtags like #MuteTyrus, #FixGutfeld, and #LetOthersTalk are now trending among conservative and independent viewers alike—an unusual alignment in a media landscape often split along political lines.

What Went Wrong?

When Gutfeld! debuted in its current format, it quickly found success by carving out a distinct lane: a late-night show with political bite and comedic timing. Greg Gutfeld’s monologues drew loyal viewers, while rotating panelists like Kat Timpf and Emily Compagno helped create a lively, conversational rhythm.

Tyrus’s larger-than-life personality initially brought a unique flavor to the show, often injecting offbeat perspectives and deadpan one-liners. But in recent months, viewers say his presence has become more disruptive than entertaining.

“He talks over everyone—every single time,” one viewer wrote in a post with thousands of likes. “What happened to balance? What happened to chemistry?”

Some now refer to segments featuring Tyrus as the “Tyrus Monologue,” a nod to how often he dominates discussions, sometimes at the expense of more nuanced or humorous dialogue.

Ratings Dip and Audience Fatigue

While Gutfeld! still leads the late-night cable pack in overall ratings, recent Nielsen data shows slippage in key demographics, particularly among viewers aged 25–54—a group that had been central to the show’s rise.

According to media analyst Nancy Field, the show is at a “critical juncture.”

“Viewers will forgive a bad joke,” Field says, “but they won’t stick around if they feel steamrolled. The essence of Gutfeld! was always about multiple voices riffing off one another. That rhythm is broken.”

Indeed, many fans say they still tune in for Gutfeld himself—but are quick to tune out when Tyrus dominates the segment.

A Growing Dilemma for Greg Gutfeld

So far, host Greg Gutfeld has remained publicly silent on the matter, despite the rising outcry. The dilemma he faces is not simple: Tyrus is not just a co-host—he’s a longtime collaborator and fan-favorite among certain segments of the audience. His bold personality helped shape the tone of the show’s early days.

But as more fans call for change, the pressure on Gutfeld to act is mounting.

Some propose small adjustments: limiting Tyrus’s airtime, setting clearer speaking turns among panelists, or reintroducing more guest variety to shift the spotlight. Others are demanding bolder moves—specifically, that Tyrus be taken off the show entirely.

“Greg has to decide,” said one YouTube commenter. “Is this about loyalty to one person, or loyalty to the audience that made the show a hit?”

What This Means for Tyrus—and for the Show

The controversy could have long-term implications for both Gutfeld! and Tyrus himself. Once hailed as a refreshing voice, Tyrus is now facing a reputational turning point. Can he adjust his on-air style—or has the backlash grown too strong?

“Tyrus brings something unique, no doubt,” said another media analyst. “But if that uniqueness turns into dominance, the chemistry breaks down—and that’s what we’re seeing.”

The show’s producers now face a critical choice: evolve the format to reflect audience feedback, or risk bleeding viewers as dissatisfaction grows.

A Reflection of a Bigger Trend?

While the debate may seem isolated to one cable show, it taps into broader cultural tensions about voice, space, and the balance of dialogue. In an era where public discourse is often dominated by the loudest voices, many viewers are calling for a return to respectful exchange—especially in entertainment formats built on conversation and comedy.

Tyrus is a symbol of that tension, one fan posted. “Do we want shows to be a roundtable—or a one-man show with others sitting silently?”

What Happens Next?

Fox News has not commented on the situation, and there’s no indication that immediate changes will be made. But insiders say the production team is well aware of the viewer dissatisfaction, and internal conversations about segment structure and tone are already underway.

The next few episodes of Gutfeld! could prove decisive. Will producers rein in the imbalance and restore the ensemble dynamic? Or will they double down on the current format, risking further alienation of the show’s base?

One thing is clear: fans are no longer watching quietly. And unless changes are made, some may stop watching altogether.